Ask Gator

13 13

What is the last book you held in your hands that made your pulse quicken, and how long ago was that?

Hey Gator,

How would you rank these GA titles based on collectability and value? I'm specifically trying to see where Young Allies and All Winners rank.

Captain America

Marvel Mystery Comics

Young Allies

All Winners

All Select

Submariner

Human Torch

Thanks again.

Hey Gator,

 

How would you rank these GA titles based on collectability and value? I'm specifically trying to see where Young Allies and All Winners rank.

 

Captain America

Marvel Mystery Comics

Young Allies

All Winners

All Select

Submariner

Human Torch

 

Thanks again.

That's easy, at the Bottom

Young Allies definitely at the bottom. I'd put All Winners (with All Select) below Captain America and Marvel Mystery and above Human Torch and Sub Mariner. Of course it totally depends on the comic. I'd put many of the Human Torch and Sub Mariner War issues above the later All Winners/All Select (and even later Marvel Mystery and Captain America).

Roughly I'd put them

WW II Issues of Captain America

WW II (and pre WW II) issues of Marvel Mystery

WW II issues of All Select

WW II issues of All Winners

Post WW II issues of Captain America

WW II issues of Human Torch

WW II issues of Sub-Mariner

Post WW II issues of Marvel Mystery

Post WW II issues of All Select

Post WW II issues of All Winner

WW II issues of Young Allies

Post WW II issues of Human Torch

Post WW II issues of Sub-Mariner

Post WW II issues of Young Allies.

NB: I'm not G.A.tor.

Hey Gator,

 

How would you rank these GA titles based on collectability and value? I'm specifically trying to see where Young Allies and All Winners rank.

 

Captain America

Marvel Mystery Comics

Young Allies

All Winners

All Select

Submariner

Human Torch

 

Thanks again.

I would rank them, top to bottom:

capt America

all select

mmc

all winners

human torch

subby

young allies...

Hey Gator,

 

How would you rank these GA titles based on collectability and value? I'm specifically trying to see where Young Allies and All Winners rank.

 

Captain America

Marvel Mystery Comics

Young Allies

All Winners

All Select

Submariner

Human Torch

 

Thanks again.

I would rank them, top to bottom:

capt America

all select

mmc

all winners

human torch

subby

young allies...

USA wasn't part of the question

USA wasn't part of the question

Young Allies definitely at the bottom. I'd put All Winners (with All Select) below Captain America and Marvel Mystery and above Human Torch and Sub Mariner. Of course it totally depends on the comic. I'd put many of the Human Torch and Sub Mariner War issues above the later All Winners/All Select (and even later Marvel Mystery and Captain America).

 

Roughly I'd put them

WW II Issues of Captain America

WW II (and pre WW II) issues of Marvel Mystery

WW II issues of All Select

WW II issues of All Winners

Post WW II issues of Captain America

WW II issues of Human Torch

WW II issues of Sub-Mariner

Post WW II issues of Marvel Mystery

Post WW II issues of All Select

Post WW II issues of All Winner

WW II issues of Young Allies

Post WW II issues of Human Torch

Post WW II issues of Sub-Mariner

Post WW II issues of Young Allies.

 

NB: I'm not G.A.tor.

With a couple of exceptions, I always figured the reason Young Allies' even sell for what they do, is because they seem cheap compared to other Timelys. It still surprises me that one can pick up a 1st issue/1st appearance Timely with a combo Kirby Red Skull and Hitler cover for as little as YA #1 runs.

This is the kind of thing that gives you guys a bad name.

This is the kind of thing that gives you guys a bad name.

 

That's a crock! Don't worry, Gator has a thick skin.

This is the kind of thing that gives you guys a bad name.

 

 

That's a crock! Don't worry, Gator has a thick skin.

Acquitted on a technicality!

Dear Gator:

Who would you think should play the part of Little Dot in an upcoming movie, and will that raise the value of Little Dot comics?

This is the kind of thing that gives you guys a bad name.

 

Dear Gator:

 

Who would you think should play the part of Little Dot in an upcoming movie, and will that raise the value of Little Dot comics?

Taylor swift. And sell now!

Katie Perry could make it work.

Katie Perry could make it work.

Katie Perry could make it work.

only if she would do the nude scenes and keep her trap shut