~~THE~~GIVING~~TREE~~

6 6

I suck at grading. I would have thought a 5.5 or something!

I suck at grading. I would have thought a 5.5 or something!

Wow. You would probably get anywhere from 3.0 - 4.0 in the Grading Thread. I'm in the 3.5 camp. Still a nice presenting book.

It was a 4.0 average in the grading thread, some had higher and some had lower.

It definitely presents higher than the grade.

Peace,

Chip

I suck at grading. I would have thought a 5.5 or something!

 

Wow. You would probably get anywhere from 3.0 - 4.0 in the Grading Thread. I'm in the 3.5 camp. Still a nice presenting book.

No, I was being completely serious. I have no idea how to grade on older types of books. I need a class or something.

It was a 4.0 average in the grading thread, some had higher and some had lower.

 

It definitely presents higher than the grade.

 

Peace,

 

Chip

See, I was right. It was a 5.5!

eBay NM!!

Is 115 or 110 first Dr strange? I see mixed listings on ebay

Yes.

thats what i thought

My offer - Strange Tales #115 - VG 4.0 with CR/OW pages - Origin of Doctor Strange & 2nd Appearance of Sandman

 

 

Peace,

 

Chip

It was a 4.0 average in the grading thread, some had higher and some had lower.

 

It definitely presents higher than the grade.

 

Peace,

 

Chip

Or just call it an ebay 5.5

Ouch - the kids gloves come off with that one. For people who did not look at the sellers name - it's the same book being offered up.

option A) take all 4 books, all are complete and intact

very nice book besides spine split up half of book starting at the bottom

Has a little staple rust

spine split from top of book too top staple

Option B) Thor 165, ide call it a 3.0-3.5

I think everyone knows. Im still curious what option was taken in the prior offer.

Wow, so it was listed as 5.5 on eBay but call it a 4.0 on the boards? Same book? What the?

I think everyone knows. Im still curious what option was taken in the prior offer.

He took option E which was pretty much one of ComicalGems $150 mystery boxes. Right now it could be a box containing a X-Factor 6 and ASM 361 or several others. Very nice offer.

I found this at a comic shop in Indiana

BANG

I see 3 books

Seriously…I think Kav and this board are single handedly raising the stock of Woodgod.

At this rate, he'll be appearing in a post credit sequence in some future Marvel movie.