Page 2 of 3 <123>
Topic Options
#5773554 - 06/15/12 06:52 PM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: bomber-bob]
Clouded9 Offline
Collectosaurus Rex


Registered: 12/29/10
Posts: 400
Loc: The Nexus in Texas
 Originally Posted By: bomber-bob

Don't Signature Service books get higher registry points ? Is a Stan Lee signed book really rare anymore ?


I thought I saw a DC book Stan signed last year. He must have thought Solomon Grundy was the Grey Hulk!

I think a silver age book that Stan actually wrote being signed by him is still neat, but not rare. I have one myself (Spectacular Spider-Man #1 from 1968). What I don't understand is getting Stan to sign a modern or copper age book that he didn't even work on. \(shrug\)

Not to open the flood gates of hate, but I don't think Sig Series books should get more registry points anyway as sigs do not change the structural integrity of the book (unless the person signing it does not handle it properly and damages it). A 9.4 SS is still just a 9.4 book. I won't say anymore as there are already several threads on the boards dedicated to this topic already. Just my opinion.
_________________________
My CAF Gallery and My Feedback/Kudos Thread



Top
Share
#5773563 - 06/15/12 06:57 PM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: Clouded9]
rtecbot Offline
Up 20 words per minute since I signed up


Registered: 09/11/10
Posts: 1274
Loc: Maryland
Page Quality of the book can also change while the book is in the slab. I have had books that went down in page quality upon resubmission.
_________________________
A house without books is like a room without windows....a room perfect for comic books.

An artist is not paid for his labor but for his vision....thats why sketches take so long to finish.

Top
#5773619 - 06/15/12 07:21 PM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: rtecbot]
bomber-bob Offline
Pedigreed


Registered: 10/14/08
Posts: 5883
Loc: Western Suburbs of Chicago
 Originally Posted By: rtecbot
Page Quality of the book can also change while the book is in the slab. I have had books that went down in page quality upon resubmission.


And so can the grade. How does that matter. The discussion is should the Registry recognize higher Page Quality with more points.

Top
#5774326 - 06/16/12 12:13 AM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: bomber-bob]
mysterio Offline
TOTAL NEWBIE


Registered: 06/25/10
Posts: 8385
Loc: Between TX and KS
 Originally Posted By: bomber-bob
 Originally Posted By: rtecbot
Page Quality of the book can also change while the book is in the slab. I have had books that went down in page quality upon resubmission.


And so can the grade. How does that matter. The discussion is should the Registry recognize higher Page Quality with more points.


Both grade and PQ can change on a resub, which reflects the inherent subjectivity of grading. But when a book is in the slab it is what it is. And a 9.4 with white pages has more desirability to many collectors than the same 9.4 with OW or CR-OW pages, and it will cost more, so the registry should reflect that.
_________________________
RIP Amazing Fantasy #15 club (7/8/2008 - 2/7/2015)

Top
#5774360 - 06/16/12 12:28 AM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: rtecbot]
ramrod44 Offline
I am gonna miss that car.


Registered: 02/06/06
Posts: 233
Loc: Ur mom's house
Don't forget about added points for pedigrees!
_________________________
[URL=http://comics.www.collectors-society.com/registry/comics/PeopleSetDetail.aspx?PeopleSetID=58897][/

Top
#5774993 - 06/16/12 01:20 PM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: ramrod44]
bomber-bob Offline
Pedigreed


Registered: 10/14/08
Posts: 5883
Loc: Western Suburbs of Chicago
 Originally Posted By: ramrod44
Don't forget about added points for pedigrees!


Though I would like to see that happen, I don't think it will. For starters it would be more difficult to implement. All peds are not created equal. I would hate to see a Mohawk Valley get the same ped bump as a Mile High Church copy.

Top
#5775137 - 06/16/12 02:41 PM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: bomber-bob]
surfer99 Offline
Up 20 words per minute since I signed up


Registered: 07/10/08
Posts: 1298
Loc: Chandler, AZ
Bagofleas made a great comment on another journal- CGC has never kept track of Page Quality (or Pedigrees) so assigning point value based on that would be difficult. Better that they focus on easily fixed flaws in the current system.
_________________________


Top
#5775187 - 06/16/12 02:59 PM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: surfer99]
mysterio Offline
TOTAL NEWBIE


Registered: 06/25/10
Posts: 8385
Loc: Between TX and KS
 Originally Posted By: surfer99
Bagofleas made a great comment on another journal- CGC has never kept track of Page Quality (or Pedigrees) so assigning point value based on that would be difficult. Better that they focus on easily fixed flaws in the current system.



Any time a book is listed in the registry it shows the PQ in the issue listing. If you used a multiplier like I suggested CGC wouldn't have to track anything. A book would get a base value like it does now, and then the PQ multiplier would be applied to that. One more instruction in the code would accomplish it easily.
_________________________
RIP Amazing Fantasy #15 club (7/8/2008 - 2/7/2015)

Top
#5775221 - 06/16/12 03:12 PM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: mysterio]
Professor Pecora Offline
If I just sell the car, I can up my bid...


Registered: 02/10/12
Posts: 157
Loc: Atlanta, GA
I like this idea! \(thumbs u
_________________________


Top
#5776515 - 06/17/12 12:02 AM Re: Ideas For Enhancing CGC Competitive Sets: Page Quality Points [Re: Professor Pecora]
surfer99 Offline
Up 20 words per minute since I signed up


Registered: 07/10/08
Posts: 1298
Loc: Chandler, AZ
I don't know that it makes a difference, but while page quality and pedigrees are listed on the registry, they're not listed on the census. If adding points for page quality is as simple as you say though, I'm all for it! \:\)


_________________________


Top
Page 2 of 3 <123>


Moderator:  plitch, Architecht, cgcmod4, cgcmod7, cgcmod6, cgcmod5, cgcmod3, Gemma, CCGmod0, cgcmod8, Barbara T, Matt Nelson, cgcmod9, cgcmod10, cgcmod11, cgcmod12, ccgmod1, PaulS., ccgmod2, Bree 
Hop to:
Boards Information
Please read the
TERMS OF USE - BOARD GUIDELINES
for the rules of moderation on the boards.



Search
The Money Marketplace
GreatCollections - Auctions Today - 1895-O $1 NGC 62, Pop 1 Platinum, Saints...
by ianrussell
06:23 PM
WTB: common date NGC ATB Quarter MS69
by Kapimono
03:46 PM
FS: NGC graded 1862 & 1909-S Indian Head Cents
by thabeast
03:00 PM
Jules Reiver Collection - Heritage catalog Volume II January 2006
by Zebo
11:19 AM
Comics Marketplace
Pasta Pimp C2E2 Modern Sale
by Jimmy Linguini
03:10 AM
Selling CGC comics plus lot of Hulk comics w/271 & 340 and Legends set
by elove
11:52 PM
Wolverine 1 J Scott Campbell Deadpool Variant cgc 9.8
by sleeper13
10:33 PM
Detective Comics 36 and 52
by AnkurJ
10:29 PM
Advertisements

Generated in 0.018 seconds in which 0.002 seconds were spent on a total of 14 queries. Zlib compression enabled.

Aspen Titles IDW Publishing