Registered: 12/08/07
Posts: 30216
Loc: Virginia, USA
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
So three sales from the past four months reflect excitement from the 90's only, and not the market value of the book?
That would be like the $1,500 sale of Primer 5 CGC 9.8 not counting towards points assigned because there must not be much of a need or there would be more graded. Anyone with any experience with this book knows it is tough to track down in higher grades, though Chuck Gower landed another Primer 5 CGC 9.8 recently. So do we assume the book shouldn't be assigned higher points because people were just not going out of their way to find it, and there are really many more available raw for those 90's collectors that appreciated Sam Kieth? And you dug up a Primer 5 CGC 9.6 recently, so there must be more out there.
The reverse-logic so you can throw out a Primer 6 jab is just showing what the attacks are all about, rather than even consideration for everyone's requests. But at least you got that jab in rather than move along, right?
Registered: 10/20/07
Posts: 15455
Loc: Vernon Hills, IL
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
Yep. What's particularly telling is that the only graded sales of this book in 9.6 or above since 2006 have been the three that were just quoted; all from the same submission, the same seller and with free shipping to boot. This book was hot for a minute back in the mid 2000s, but pretending that demand has been on an uptick since then is wishful thinking more than anything ...
_________________________ Looking for: Neil Gaiman rarities Cerebus #1 in VF/NM or better
Registered: 12/08/07
Posts: 30216
Loc: Virginia, USA
Originally Posted By: mschmidt
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
Yep. What's particularly telling is that the only graded sales of this book in 9.6 or above since 2006 have been the three that were just quoted; all from the same submission, the same seller and with free shipping to boot. This book was hot for a minute back in the mid 2000s, but pretending that demand has been on an uptick since then is wishful thinking more than anything ...
Interesting. Three sales of 9.6's within the past four months, and you still stand by your premise there is little to no demand? There have been no other 9.6's posted for sale in the past year on Ebay, so it seems odd to blow them off as not being representative of market value.
And I had a feeling the free shipping would enter into the discussion. Does GPA discount for shipping costs included in the price?
#5583304 - 04/07/1201:26 PMRe: The Official "Hey, these scores need fixing" thread (Revised)
[Re: Bosco685]
AGGIEZAGGIEZ Did you really just "Funny post" your own post?
TOTAL NEWBIE
Registered: 02/09/08
Posts: 6609
Loc: Steel City
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
The reverse-logic so you can throw out a Primer 6 jab is just showing what the attacks are all about, rather than even consideration for everyone's requests. But at least you got that jab in rather than move along, right?
Not really sure what you're talking about here. I think the comparison of the 1st appearance books of two currently irrelevant characters that were popular in the 90's was valid.
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
And I had a feeling the free shipping would enter into the discussion. Does GPA discount for shipping costs included in the price?
I don't believe they do. No discount on the most recent sale. Not really apples-to-apples to sales that require shipping $$ in my opinion.
Registered: 12/08/07
Posts: 30216
Loc: Virginia, USA
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
The reverse-logic so you can throw out a Primer 6 jab is just showing what the attacks are all about, rather than even consideration for everyone's requests. But at least you got that jab in rather than move along, right?
Not really sure what you're talking about here. I think the comparison of the 1st appearance books of two currently irrelevant characters that were popular in the 90's was valid.
#5583407 - 04/07/1201:47 PMRe: The Official "Hey, these scores need fixing" thread (Revised)
[Re: Bosco685]
AGGIEZAGGIEZ Did you really just "Funny post" your own post?
TOTAL NEWBIE
Registered: 02/09/08
Posts: 6609
Loc: Steel City
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
The reverse-logic so you can throw out a Primer 6 jab is just showing what the attacks are all about, rather than even consideration for everyone's requests. But at least you got that jab in rather than move along, right?
Not really sure what you're talking about here. I think the comparison of the 1st appearance books of two currently irrelevant characters that were popular in the 90's was valid.
Razor Annual 1 (1993)
Primer 6 (1984)
I guess you're right, Evangeline hasn't been popular since the 80's...my bad
Registered: 12/08/07
Posts: 30216
Loc: Virginia, USA
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
The reverse-logic so you can throw out a Primer 6 jab is just showing what the attacks are all about, rather than even consideration for everyone's requests. But at least you got that jab in rather than move along, right?
Not really sure what you're talking about here. I think the comparison of the 1st appearance books of two currently irrelevant characters that were popular in the 90's was valid.
Razor Annual 1 (1993)
Primer 6 (1984)
I guess you're right, Evangeline hasn't been popular since the 80's...my bad
And once again, the registry forum area is raised up by your passive-aggressive ways.
#5583429 - 04/07/1201:54 PMRe: The Official "Hey, these scores need fixing" thread (Revised)
[Re: Bosco685]
AGGIEZAGGIEZ Did you really just "Funny post" your own post?
TOTAL NEWBIE
Registered: 02/09/08
Posts: 6609
Loc: Steel City
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
Originally Posted By: Bosco685
Originally Posted By: AGGIEZ
There are only 14 graded. If the book were so desireable the census numbers would reflect this. I don't think the fact that the book is rarely slabbed means the book is rare...only borderline slab-worthy. The 6 Shi fans out there were willing to spend $70-80 to feed their nostalgia, thus you GPA sales you reference....
May have been a cool book to own in the 90's, alla Primer #6, but there are very few that are willing to spend much on it today or even know the book has minimal significance.
The reverse-logic so you can throw out a Primer 6 jab is just showing what the attacks are all about, rather than even consideration for everyone's requests. But at least you got that jab in rather than move along, right?
Not really sure what you're talking about here. I think the comparison of the 1st appearance books of two currently irrelevant characters that were popular in the 90's was valid.
Razor Annual 1 (1993)
Primer 6 (1984)
I guess you're right, Evangeline hasn't been popular since the 80's...my bad
And once again, the registry forum area is raised up by your passive-aggressive ways.
Said Mr. Passive-Aggressive.
I think I'm pretty straight forward. I think you're a tool, a fake, and an emoticon abuser. How's that for passive-aggressive Mr. Passive-Aggressive?
