Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread - Collectors Society Message Boards

Collectors Society

You are not logged in. [Log In]

Collectors Society Message Boards » Forums » NGC - NCS - PMG Forum » NGC Registry » Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread

Hop to:

Page 20 of 24

20

Topic Options

#4546346 - 01/20/11 10:02 PM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: leeg]
Oldtrader3 Oldtrader3 The Unknown Engineer Pedigreed Registered: 01/28/02 Posts: 5681 Loc: Western Washington	I am posting this request here because it is more of a general question about specifically cents, nickels and dimes with branch mint (i.e. 1923-S Buffs) dates in the 1920's. Many of these coins are relatively expensive in grades above VF25 but only get scores of three (3) points in the registry. I realize that this is probably low priority and has been this way from day one but you might consider raising these scores to reflect the reality of these coins being relatively expensive for some issues of branch mint coins from this era. _________________________
Top

Share

#4577600 - 02/02/11 10:02 PM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: Oldtrader3]
Oldtrader3 Oldtrader3 The Unknown Engineer Pedigreed Registered: 01/28/02 Posts: 5681 Loc: Western Washington	Thank you NGC for changing the grades on many scarcer issues from the 1920's in grades less the AU. Many of we collectors appreciate the score increase on coins that are certainly worth more than 3 points for coins from these pre and depression years. _________________________
Top

#4605334 - 02/15/11 06:06 PM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: coinman1794]
dleonard-3 dleonard-3 Collector is an understatement. Registered: 06/14/06 Posts: 143	The Registry set under US, Lincoln Cents 1959-date proofs, I noticed that the 1978-S, 1979-S type 1, 1980-S, 1981-S type 1, & 1982-S cents all score 3 points in PF69RD Ultra Cameo - which is the top grade (none better). I know, there are several hundred of each in this grade, but they still should score more than 3 points in the top grade. _________________________
Top

#5108221 - 09/22/11 10:48 PM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: jackson64]
jackson64 jackson64 Up 20 words per minute since I signed up Registered: 10/04/06 Posts: 1444 Loc: Chesapeake Bay Shore	Originally Posted By: jackson64 Too funny, however I have never noticed this thread..I have emailed and filled out the "score change request" link 3 times combined and gotten not even a computerized reply.. Hopefully I will fair better trying this link.... Dear NGC, would you please consider raising the scores on the.....( as per the thread guidelines..) 3. A. it is a date set/series B. Mercury Dime Short Set 1941-1945...specifically the 1945 P, D, & S star values... C. Fair Market Value: this is hard to determine since the designation can be subjective depending upon a persons tastes...however I paid over $400 for the 1945P MS67 * coin alone ( I did this so that I would have--most likely--the only collection of complete 1945 P* D* and S)... D. my reasoning/rationale is that Mercury dime coins are quite elusive...in fact, the 1945 3 coin combo in MS67* gets less than a 50% point bonus...however by comparison the 1946 PDS Rosie MS67* coins get up to a 300% bonus !!..To top it off, the 1945 MS67* coins are far rarer and more elusive... Comparison...1946P MS67* Rosie.. jumps from 437 in 67 to 1045 in 67* ( and it is multiples more common than the..) 1945P Mercury MS67*..moves from 237 to 336 ( total pop of 2 with 2 >).. Your consideration and time are appreciated..and please reply even if it is NO..so that I'll at least know that you have heard my thoughts...thank you, Jackson http://coins.www.collectors-society.com/registry/coins/SetScoreDetail.aspx?SetTypeID=165 Over 2 years later and the silence is deafening...... _________________________
Top

#5108905 - 09/23/11 10:23 AM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: jackson64]
Jerica Jerica Unregistered	Originally Posted By: jackson64 Originally Posted By: jackson64 Too funny, however I have never noticed this thread..I have emailed and filled out the "score change request" link 3 times combined and gotten not even a computerized reply.. Hopefully I will fair better trying this link.... Dear NGC, would you please consider raising the scores on the.....( as per the thread guidelines..) 3. A. it is a date set/series B. Mercury Dime Short Set 1941-1945...specifically the 1945 P, D, & S star values... C. Fair Market Value: this is hard to determine since the designation can be subjective depending upon a persons tastes...however I paid over $400 for the 1945P MS67 * coin alone ( I did this so that I would have--most likely--the only collection of complete 1945 P* D* and S)... D. my reasoning/rationale is that Mercury dime coins are quite elusive...in fact, the 1945 3 coin combo in MS67* gets less than a 50% point bonus...however by comparison the 1946 PDS Rosie MS67* coins get up to a 300% bonus !!..To top it off, the 1945 MS67* coins are far rarer and more elusive... Comparison...1946P MS67* Rosie.. jumps from 437 in 67 to 1045 in 67* ( and it is multiples more common than the..) 1945P Mercury MS67*..moves from 237 to 336 ( total pop of 2 with 2 >).. Your consideration and time are appreciated..and please reply even if it is NO..so that I'll at least know that you have heard my thoughts...thank you, Jackson http://coins.www.collectors-society.com/registry/coins/SetScoreDetail.aspx?SetTypeID=165 Over 2 years later and the silence is deafening...... Hi Jackson64, I do apologize that you have had to fill out a score correction form three times without a reply. We at NGC do our very best to always reply promptly to all of our e-mails, questions, and concerns that our members send us. We will review your request for the score change of the 1945 P, D, and S coin in the Mercury Dime Short Set 1941-1945 and make any appropriate updates. I will e-mail you with any changes as soon as they are made. If you have any further questions or concerns please feel free to either message me on here or directly to my e-mail at jgarcia@ngccoin.com.
Top

#5109929 - 09/23/11 05:21 PM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: jackson64]
Jerica Jerica Unregistered	Originally Posted By: jackson64 Originally Posted By: jackson64 Too funny, however I have never noticed this thread..I have emailed and filled out the "score change request" link 3 times combined and gotten not even a computerized reply.. Hopefully I will fair better trying this link.... Dear NGC, would you please consider raising the scores on the.....( as per the thread guidelines..) 3. A. it is a date set/series B. Mercury Dime Short Set 1941-1945...specifically the 1945 P, D, & S star values... C. Fair Market Value: this is hard to determine since the designation can be subjective depending upon a persons tastes...however I paid over $400 for the 1945P MS67 * coin alone ( I did this so that I would have--most likely--the only collection of complete 1945 P* D* and S)... D. my reasoning/rationale is that Mercury dime coins are quite elusive...in fact, the 1945 3 coin combo in MS67* gets less than a 50% point bonus...however by comparison the 1946 PDS Rosie MS67* coins get up to a 300% bonus !!..To top it off, the 1945 MS67* coins are far rarer and more elusive... Comparison...1946P MS67* Rosie.. jumps from 437 in 67 to 1045 in 67* ( and it is multiples more common than the..) 1945P Mercury MS67*..moves from 237 to 336 ( total pop of 2 with 2 >).. Your consideration and time are appreciated..and please reply even if it is NO..so that I'll at least know that you have heard my thoughts...thank you, Jackson http://coins.www.collectors-society.com/registry/coins/SetScoreDetail.aspx?SetTypeID=165 Over 2 years later and the silence is deafening...... Hi Jackson64, I have reviewed the scores in the "Mercury Dimes, 1941-1945, Circulation Issue" set and updated the scores for the 1945 P, D, and S. If you have any further questions or concerns you can message me on here or send me an e-mail at jgarcia@ngccoin.com.
Top

#5151691 - 10/12/11 09:52 AM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: ]
Oldtrader3 Oldtrader3 The Unknown Engineer Pedigreed Registered: 01/28/02 Posts: 5681 Loc: Western Washington	Would you please consider updating the scopes of the 1879-P Double Eagle. In MS grades they are very scarce and only receive 1450 points for an MS60 coin that is selling for $2500. They are a lot scarcer in MS grades than they are crdedited for. All of the 1879 gold is pretty low mintage with less then 150 certified coins over MS60 and hard to find. Thank you for your consideration. Edited by Oldtrader3 (10/12/11 09:56 AM) _________________________
Top

#5353569 - 01/05/12 09:48 PM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: Oldtrader3]
MorganMan MorganMan Up 20 words per minute since I signed up Registered: 08/20/06 Posts: 1150 Loc: South Georgia, US	Hey NGC, would you please check the set listed as #1 on the 20th Anniversary American Eagle sets. The PCGS coins are scored higher than NGC coins, plus the same coin is listed for two different positions. http://coins.www.collectors-society.com/registry/Coins/SetListing.aspx?PeopleSetID=122561 Something is way wrong here.... MM _________________________ We can evade reality, but we cannot evade the consequences of evading reality
Top

#5373491 - 01/13/12 10:26 PM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: MorganMan]
Lehigh96 Lehigh96 The Post-man always rings twice. Uhm... ring ring? Registered: 03/28/08 Posts: 1884 Loc: The Poker Room	I don't know whether NGC is working on this or not but it is incomplete. The point values for the 1943-P DDO were changed on 11/7/2011. This is a welcome change and long overdue since the 1943-P DDO is one of the most important varieties of the entire Jefferson Nickel series. However, the 1943-P DDO 5FS & 6FS are much more rare and the scores have not yet been changed. Can we expect to see revised point values for the full step 1943-P DDO in the near future? Jefferson Nickels Coin Score: 1943-P The population of the 1943-P DDO MS67 5FS is 3/0. IMO, the score should be equal to or greater than that of the 1943/2-P MS67 5FS which is 2585. _________________________ Lehigh Coins Link: http://Support-the-Collectors-Society.com/Lehigh-Coins?_trksid=p4340.l2563
Top

#5385159 - 01/19/12 08:58 AM Re: Official "Hey please check these scores" Thread [Re: Lehigh96]
Jwillie33 Jwillie33 Hobbyist Registered: 07/03/06 Posts: 35 Loc: Alabama	Okay, now that the DDO scores have been upgraded please move the non DDo 1943-P 5FS and 6FS scores back to where they were. I appreciate the higher score, but this makes my nickel score look way skewed and I have nothing in there to merit the higher score. Thanks. _________________________
Top

Page 20 of 24

20

Previous Topic

Previous Topic View All Topics

View All Topics

Index Next Topic

Next Topic

Moderator: ngcmod, dena, Jay Turner, CCGmod0, PaulS., Barbara T

Hop to:

Boards Information

Please read the
TERMS OF USE - BOARD GUIDELINES
for the rules of moderation on the boards.

The Money Marketplace

FSH; A couple of toners from 1945
by cucamongacoin
06:13 PM

GreatCollections - Coin Auctions Today - Classic Gold, Lincoln Cents, ASEs...
by ianrussell
04:05 PM

Sold!
by 123cents
11:45 AM

FSH Washington quarters PCGS MS65 4 different dates
by jayman1970
11:23 AM

Comics Marketplace

Venom's Mystery Boxes
by Venom

Catman 28 on eBay
by Larryw7

ASM 90 91 92 raw lot bundle
by heymikesays
06:49 PM

1st App Wolverine and New X-Men! Hulk 181 8.5 and GS X-Men 1 9.0
by woregul
05:18 PM

Advertisements

Generated in 0.017 seconds in which 0.006 seconds were spent on a total of 14 queries. Zlib compression enabled.